The ‘best time to post’ myth (and what actually matters)


Hi Reader,

If you’ve seen my posts this week about posting times, crossposting, and the algorithm, I want to zoom out for a second - because this is where a LOT of people get stuck.

Most advice still sounds like this:

“Post at 8:17 AM on Tuesdays or the algorithm will ignore you.”

And when that doesn’t work, people assume they did something wrong.

Here’s the part that rarely gets said clearly:

The algorithm doesn’t care what time it is. It cares how people react.

Posting times matter a little - but not in the way most people think.

They don’t determine whether your content is “good” or “bad.” They just help your post get its first few eyes.

What actually decides whether your post gets shown more is:

  • Do people stop scrolling?
  • Do they interact quickly?
  • Do they linger, save, or share?

That’s it.

Which is also why crossposting works far better than people expect.

When you:

  • Share the same post across platforms
  • Use a consistent message
  • Let each platform test it with different audiences

You’re not being “lazy”... you’re being efficient.

One post can:

  • Flop on Instagram
  • Do fine on Facebook
  • Take off days later as a Reel

That doesn’t mean the content was wrong. It means algorithms test, not judge.

This is why I always say:

Consistency + clarity will beat perfect timing every time.

If posting has felt stressful, it’s usually not because you need better timing, it’s because you’ve been trying to:

  • Guess the algorithm
  • Rewrite the same idea 5 different ways
  • Or decide where something “should” go before you ever post it

The truth? Pick a reasonable time. Crosspost confidently. Let the platform do its job.

If this week’s posts made you exhale a little and think, “Okay… maybe I don’t need to overthink this,” then they did exactly what I hoped they would.

And if you want to keep having these kinds of conversations (the ones that make marketing feel calmer and more doable) that’s exactly what my free community is for.

No pressure, no perfect posting required. Just clarity, real talk, and support from people who get it.
Join the free community

Cheers,

P.S. No one sees all of your content anyway - which means reposting, crossposting, and repeating yourself is not only allowed… it’s necessary.



Cindy Slack | Massage Marketing Membership
she/her
Helping massage therapists market smarter, not harder ✨
26+ yrs LMT | Cofounder @BodyworkBuddy 💆🏻‍♀️
Done-for-you social & email 💌
Follow me on Instagram for stress-free marketing tips!
@Massage_marketing_done_for_you
Join the free community